Developing a Sense of Place Through Native Science Activities
Originally appears in the Spring 2010 issue
“The traditional Indian understanding of land focuses on its use, and the duties people assume when they come to occupy it. When an Indian thinks about traditional lands, he always talks about what the people did there, the animals who lived there and how the people related to them, the seasons of the year and how people responded to their changes, the manner in which the tribe acquired possession of the area, and the ceremonial functions it was required to perform to remain worthy of living there” Vine Deloria, Jr.
A few months ago, I received my copy of Green Teacher in the mail and there on the front cover was a picture of a classroom without a wall. The indoor classroom seamlessly flowed into the outdoor classroom. The theme of the issue (Fall 2009), “Two-Eyed Seeing: Integrative Science”, puzzled me. What could that mean? In the lead article, authors Hatcher, Bartlett, Marshall and Marshall explained that two-eyed seeing means “…bringing together [of] Indigenous and Western knowledge … to see from one eye with the strengths of Indigenous ways of knowing, and from the other eye with the strengths of Western ways of knowing, and to use both of these eyes together”.
Tewa teacher and author, Gregory Cajete calls this Indigenous way of knowing “Native science”. He believes that in order to understand this way of doing science, a person has to know how Indigenous people participate with the natural world and what their worldviews are. He states, “Native science is a broad term that can include metaphysics and philosophy; art and architecture; practical technologies and agriculture; and ritual and ceremony practiced by Indigenous peoples both past and present (Cajete, 2009, p. 2). Western science is more narrowly defined and does not include all these other disciplines. Western science is a part of Native science but it does not venture deeply into areas of the mystical.
According to Cajete, Native science requires understanding the roles of sensation, perception, imagination, emotion, and spirit in seeking knowledge. He believes that “the cosmological and philosophical must once again become ‘rooted’ in a life-centered, lived experience of the natural world” (2000, p. 5). In other words, Native science incorporates indigenous belief systems that go beyond logic, objectivity, and rational empiricism. Much of Native science, like matters of spirituality, is difficult to express in words. Because some skeptics doubt the existence of Native science, this is a controversial area among scientists. These critics dismiss Native science as simply animism or worship of nature. They believe that Western science is culturally neutral and should not be affected by how humans view the origin of the earth, ethical conduct, and life after death.
The following activities have been inspired by the writings of people who have lived close to the land and have had a deep sense of their places. These writers could be described as indigenous people. “The word, ‘indigenous’, is derived from the Latin root indu or endo that is related to the Greek word, endina meaning, entrails. “Indigenous means being so completely identified with a place that you reflect its very entrails, its soul.”
Some of these activities could be included in what is commonly described as Western science. For example, Western science involves orienting to a place, naming nature, comparing, writing, using the five senses, attending to details, magnifying objects, finding patterns, and questioning. However, Native science goes beyond Western science when it includes telling non-factual stories, listening to the landscape speak, being felt by nature, speaking to the earth, feeling rootedness to the earth, giving back after taking something (reciprocity), asking permission of the earth, creating art, ritual, and ceremony.
- Orienting To a Place
“The four (or more) cardinal directions generally serve as allegories for sacred orientations to places in Indigenous traditions. Each has associated plants, animals, and natural phenomena. An each of the plants and animals represents a perspective, a way of looking at something in the center that humans are trying to know” –Gregory Cajete
Select something outdoors like a plant, rock, animal, or other object to examine carefully. Look at it from the four cardinal directions (north, east, south, and west) and from above and below if you can. How does changing your viewing direction change what you see?
- Changing Positions
“Entomology extends the limits of being in a new direction, so that I walk in Nature with a sense of greater space and freedom. It suggest, beside, that the universe is not rough-hewn, but perfect in its details. Nature will bear the closest inspection; she invites us to lay our eye level with the smallest leaf and take an insect view of its plain. She has no interstices; every part is full of life” –Henry David Thoreau
Follow Thoreau’s suggestion of lying down so your eye level is as low as the leaves on the ground to take an insect’s view of the ground. What can you sense from that position?
- Understanding Yourself
“What people make of their places is closely connected to what they make of themselves as members of society and inhabitants of the earth” –Keith H. Basso
Go to a special place, sit alone there for a while, and write a paragraph about that place. Then join the group and talk about how what you wrote relates to what you know and who you are. Do you agree that the place helped you understand yourself?
- Telling Stories
Many Native stories are “spatially anchored” or centered in specific places. In Yurok tradition stories were told to teach life lessons. “Wherever you went the sight of an animal, the call of a bird, the presence of a rock reminded you of an instructional story” –Margolin
Many Native stories are “spatially anchored” or centred in specific places. In Yurok tradition, stories were told to teach life lessons. Select a location and create a teaching story that is connected to that place. Share it with others. How can stories about places teach lessons?
- Naming Places
“For [the Kwakiutl], a name was a story. We say ‘Vancouver,’ naming an island for a captain; we say ‘Victoria,’ naming a village for a queen. For them, a place-name would not be something that is, but something that happens. They called one patch of ocean ‘Where salmon gather.’ They called one bend in the river ‘Insufficient canoe.’ . . . If the Kwakiutl habits of naming were childlike, naïve, they were also utterly mature. Their language shows connections where we have made separations.” –Kim Stafford
Name a place using a brief descriptive phrase or sentence that tells a story of what is happening or has happened there. Then share the name with others to see if they can guess where that place is and where you were when you named that place. Do you know of other places that describe what happened there?
- Naming Plants and Animals
“It was his [Ohiyesa’s uncle] custom to let me name all the new birds that I had seen during the day. I would name them according to the color or shape of the bill or their song or the appearance and locality of the nest – in fact, anything about the bird that impressed me as characteristic” –Charles Eastman (Ohiyesa)
Name some plants or animals as though you were the first person to ever see them. Select names describing a physical characteristic or behavior of the plants or animals. Do you know other plant and animal names that indicate their physical characteristics or behavior?
“Ideas about the habitat are frequently set in elaborate similes and metaphors which equate disparate objects in a fashion that at first seems quite unfathomable” –Paul Radin writing about the Winnebago (Ho-Chunk) Indians
Select something in your place and create a simile (a figure of speech comparing two things using “like” or “as”) or a metaphor (a figure of speech comparing two things directly). Did writing the similes or metaphors help you understand the things better or see it in a different way?
- Looking, Using, Communicating
“Some ethnographers (scientists involved in a branch of anthropology that considers the subdivisions and families of humans, their origin, characteristics, distribution, and other traits) believe that people interact with the landscape in a least three different ways: observing what happens there; using it in a physical way that sometimes changes it; and communicating about it to others” –Keith H. Basso
In a small group interact with a particular landscape in each of these three ways and then discuss how the members of your group responded to these different tasks. Did you discover something new about this place by doing this?
- Listening to the Landscape
“In indigenous, oral cultures, nature itself is articulate; it speaks. The human voice in an oral culture is always to some extent participant with the voices of wolves, wind, and waves – participant, that is, with the encompassing discourse of an animate earth” –David Abram
Listen to the language of the landscape. If this landscape could speak to you, what would it say? If the landscape were capable of doing something about what it just said, what would it do?
10. Listening to Water
“It is not by chance that, when hiking in the mountains, the English terms we spontaneously use to describe the surging waters of the nearby river are words like ‘rush,’ ‘splash,’ ‘gush,’ ‘wash.’ For the sound that unites all these words is that which the water itself chants as it flows between the banks” –David Abram
Sit near flowing water and listen carefully for the words you can recognize in the English (or other) language. What did you hear the water saying?
11. Feeling/Being Felt
According to Richard Nelson the Koyukon Indians of north central Alaska believe that “the surroundings are aware, sensate, personified. They feel. They can be offended. And they must, at every moment, be treated with the proper respect” –David Abram
Select a tree nearby and touch it gently. Try to feel the tree touching you and treat is with respect, gentleness, and reverence. Listen to the tree and try to learn from it. Do you think that the surroundings have soul or spirit?
12. Speaking To Nature
“This was my ‘method of study’: I drifted about from rock to rock, from stream to stream, from grove to grove. Where night found me there I camped. When I discovered a new plant, I sat down beside it for a minute or a day, to make its acquaintance and hear what it had to tell. When I came to moraines, or ice-scratches upon the rocks, I traced them back, learning what I could of the glacier that made them I asked bowlders [sic] I met, whence they came and whither they were going” –John Muir
Find a small rock and speak to it (not about it). What did you chose to say to it? Did it “speak” back to you? If so, what did it say?
13. Staying in the Present
David Abram (1996, p. 202) uses the following exercise to help him focus on the present moment and place. Give his method a try to see if it helps bring you into the “here and now”.
“I locate myself in a relatively open space . . . I relax a bit, take a few breaths, gaze around. Then I close my eyes, and let myself begin to feel the whole bulk of my past – the whole mass of events leading up to this very moment. And I call into awareness, as well, my whole future – all those projects and possibilities that lie waiting to be realized. I imagine this past and this future as two vast balloons of time, separated from each other like the bulbs of an hourglass . . . And then, very slowly, I allow both of these immense bulbs of time to begin leaking their substance into this minute moment between them, into the present. Slowly, imperceptible at first, the present moment begins to grow. Nourished by the leakage from the past and the future, the present moment swells in proportion as those other dimensions shrink. I let the past and the future dissolve entirely. And I open my eyes . . .”
“Attention in the Indigenous sense, has to do with the focus of all senses. Seeing, listening, feeling, smelling, hearing and intuiting are developed and applied in the Indigenous perspective of attention” –Gregory Cajete
Pay attention to your environment by using as many of your senses at once. Try not to think about which single sense you are using. Is this possible for you? This process is called synaesthesia, the overlapping and blending of the senses. Then try separating your senses to pay careful attention to your place. Which way of sensing is easier?
15. Feeling Rooted
“Stories are prized because of their unique capacity to enhance the experience of rootedness to place” –Belden C. Lane
Read a story about a place that helps you feel rooted there and read it. How did the story help you feel rooted? How can feeling rooted in a place help you?
16. Touching the Earth
“It was good for the skin to touch the earth and the old people like to remove their moccasins and walk with bare feet on the sacred earth” –Luther Standing Bear
“Nobody seems to have the time to touch the earth; nobody is willing to put their hands into the soil. How can you know anything important unless you do that” –Leon Shenandoah
Go to a place and remove your shoes and socks to walk barefoot on the earth. (Make sure there is nothing sharp there to injure your feet.) Also bend down and touch the ground with your palms. Does it make a difference to touch the earth directly in these ways? Do you feel the power and strength of the supporting earth?
“He [Ohiyesa’s uncle] did not expect a correct reply at once to all the voluminous questions that he put to me on these occasions, but he meant to make me observant and a good student of nature” –Charles A. Eastman
Go to a natural area and think of some important questions that might help others to observe the place closely and develop a more complete understanding of it. Select one of your questions and try to answer it yourself.
18. Magnifying the World
“The small hand lens is the perfect auxiliary to the human eye and mind. . . . It opens a door to whole new world of discovery in one’s backyard or along the woodland trail. . . . The lens takes up where the senses leave off, thereby sharpening all of them. Life, say the enthralled initiates to the world of the hand-lens, is never quite the same after that first excursion into magnification, and the enlarging of human perspective, understanding, and appreciation of the world” –Virginia S. Eifert
Explore an outdoor area using a magnifying hand lens. What new discoveries or surprises did you find?
19. Using Adverbs, Adjectives, and Verbs
“Current! That’s what makes a brook or a mighty river. Water is downhill motion. One good travel game is ‘adverb hunting,’ and streams are natural haunts for adverbs. . . Adverbs, you remember tell ‘how,’ modifying the action in verbs. How does the current flow? Swiftly, silently, swirlingly, slowly, stealthily, sluicingly, subtly. You may find adjectives easier, modifying the noun current. Fast, dashing, slow, lazy, hurrying, lingering, undercutting, depositing, circling, eddying. Or perhaps best, look for verbs. Verbs have action – and a stream always has action” –John W. Brainerd
Observe moving water or other movements in nature (e.g. trees swaying in the wind, clouds moving across the sky, bees foraging for nectar) and make lists of adverbs, adjectives and verbs to describe the motion. How does this excersise expand your awareness of the place?
20. Pledging Earth Care
Gary Snyder, a logger, poet, essayist, philosopher, and activist, wrote a poem, “For All” that contained a revised pledge of allegiance honoring our reliance on and responsibility to the land:
“I pledge allegiance to the soil
of Turtle Island,
and to the beings who thereon dwell
under the sun
With joyful interpenetration for all”
Compose a pledge of allegiance about that place that reflects how you feel about it.
21. Finding Patterns
“I responded immediately when I received Douglas Wood’s manuscript. I had recently seen a film by Richard Feather Anderson, which mentioned that in nature there are eight patterns in the way things grow. He had been inspired by a book called Patterns in Nature, by Peter S. Stevens, a teacher at MIT” –Wendy A. Halperin
Look for different patterns or designs in nature. Can you find as many patterns (8) as Stevens did?
22. Giving Back
“When the badger is alive he eats this herb. Whatever herb the badger introduces is especially good. Some consider his medicine stronger than that of the bear, as he digs deeper and farther into the ground. Eagle Shield said that he buried a little tobacco as an offering to the badger whenever he dug any of these roots” –Frances Densmore
Select a plant that you consider to be important to you and offer it to the earth as a way of saying thank you for its blessings and gifts. Some native people offer tobacco, sage, cedar, sweetgrass, or corn pollen as ways of showing gratitude. Does giving something special back to the earth help you feel more thankful?
23. Asking Permission
“You must ask permission of the plant or the medicine will not work. Plants are alive; you must give them a good talk” –Navajo Elder
When picking berries, fruits or edible plants for food or for making tea, ask the plant for permission to pick it. After picking from the plant, show your gratitude in some way. How does asking the plant for permission change the way you think about picking it?
24. Moving in Nature
“[Mary] Austin recognizes that how we move through or experience a particular natural environment can have lasting effects on how we perceive or come to value that environment” –Corey Lee Lewis
Move through a natural area in a way that you think will allow you to experience the place fully. After you do this, share with others how you chose to move through the place.
25. Recognizing Interdependence
“We are all related’ is a metaphor used by the Lakota in their prayers. It is a metaphor whose meaning is shared by all other Indian people” –Gregory Cajete
Observe your surroundings and list the ways that you are related to that place. Then list the ways that all the things in that place are related to each other. Does becoming aware of how you are related to your surroundings cause you to value it more?
Abram, D. (1996). The spell of the sensuous: Perception and language in a more-than-human world. New York: Vintage Books.
Basso, K. H. (1996). Wisdom sits in places: Landscape and language among the Western Apache. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.
Brainerd, J. W. (1986). The nature observer’s handbook: Learning to appreciate our natural world. Chester, CT: The Globe Pequot Press.
Cajete, G. (1994). Look to the mountain: An ecology of indigenous education. Durango, CO: Kivaki Press.
Cajete, G. (2000l). Native science: Natural laws of interdependence. Santa Fe, NM: Clear Light.
Cohen, M. P. The pathless way: John Muir and American wilderness. (1984). Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.
Deloria Jr., V. (2006). The world we used to live in. (2006). Golden, CO: Fulcrum Press.
Deloria, Jr., V. Out of chaos, pp. 259-269, In D. M. Dooling & P. Jordan-Smith. (1989). I become part of it. New York: Parabola.
Eastman, C. A. (1971). Indian boyhood. New York: Dover.
Eifert. V. S. (1967). Essays on nature. Springfield, IL: Illinois State Museum.
Gibson, W. H. (1902). Sharp eyes: A rambler’s calendar of fifty-two weeks among insects, birds, and flowers. New York: Harper & Brothers.
Huges, J. D. (1983). American Indian Ecology. El Paso: Texas Western Press.
LaChapelle, D. (1992). Way of the Mountain Newsletter. Silverton, CO.
Lane, B. C. (1988). Landscapes of the sacred: Geography and narrative in American spirituality. New York: Paulist Press.
Lewis, C. L. (2005). Reading the trail: Exploring the literature and natural history of the California Crest. Reno, NV: University of Nevada Press.
Margolin, M. (2005). “Indian pedagogy: A look at traditional California Indian teaching techniques” (pp. 67 – 79) in M. K. Stone & Z. Barlow (Eds.). Ecological literacy: Educating our children for a sustainable world. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books.
Mckenzie, M., Hart, P., Bai, H., & Jickling, B. (Eds.). (2009). Fields of green: Restorying culture, environment, and education. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
Wall, S. (2001). To become a human being: The message of Tadodaho Chief Leon Shenandoah. Charlottesville, VA: Hampton Roads.
Wood, D. (2006). Nothing to do. New York: Dutton Children’s Books.
To view the photo-rich magazine version, click here.
Clifford E. Knapp is a Professor Emeritus in the Teaching and Learning Department at Northern Illinois University and currently is a consultant in outdoor and place-based education. He has a deep interest in indigenous cultures for almost twenty years.